@yoregano You might try this: go to your S&S page
Switch from the delivery tab to the subscriptions tab. Select the cancelled subscriptions sub tab. Select reactivate for at least 30 items (or as many subscriptions as you have if less than 30), making sure to change the delivery schedule for each to 6 months. Then go back to your deliveries tab and skip all but 5 items. Those will be your default max saving triggers for April and October.
Next month, scroll down to your October deliveries (where all the skipped April items were moved to since you selected every 6 months) and for 5 of those items select “change your delivery schedule,” then change “next delivery by” to the current month/1st choice… these will be your max savings triggers for May and November.
Repeat for the next 4 months until you have at least 5 items scheduled for delivery every month for 6 months straight.
Every time you place a new S&S order for something you actually want delivered, skip one of the place holder items so it continues to help trigger your max discount 6 months down the line. You can set a monthly alarm for yourself to remember to skip unwanted deliveries before the deadline but it’s a good idea to pad your deliveries with items that are really cheap (makeup and office supplies are good options or pantry ingredients like baking soda… hint, hint if you don’t have 30 items to reactivate) and/or that you’re going to buy/use again anyway in case you are ever unable to cancel in time and the items get shipped (though you can still cancel orders that haven’t shipped from your order history).
I hope that makes sense. You can at least try it for a couple few months to test your theory that you’re being targeted for not actually reordering anything. You might also shop around for things that you actually do want to reorder regularly… I’m sure after all of these years that some of your S&S orders must have been repeats… it might help to occasionally let S&S reorder an item or two for you to get back in their good graces.
It you for try this, I’d advise rechecking the current price on all of your orders a day or two before the deadline because there are often price drops that make it cheaper to place a new order then cancel or skip the higher priced order.
HTH
ETA: if you have problems finding items to maintain the 5-item minimum, the 5 items don’t have to be unique, just 5 separate orders (even if they’re 5 of the same thing).